Monday, September 26, 2011

BERLIN — In the debate about the possible bankruptcy of the Greek state, one largely dormant argument has resurfaced with increasing frequency: the widespread damage inflicted by the Nazi regime during World War II means that Germany still owes Greece major wartime reparations. While the claims for payment of damages are based on very real facts, one could argue that over the course of 60 years or so, those claims have been satisfied under international law. What is at stake? Without having been provoked, the Wehrmacht — the Third Reich's armed forces — took over both Greece and Yugoslavia on April 6, 1941. In both countries, German soldiers set up a brutal occupation regime. As was usually the case in European nations invaded by the Germans, the high cost of the occupation was borne by the occupied country — and the Greek economy was plundered through forced exports. This resulted in galloping inflation and a radically lower standard of living for Greeks. Additionally, the Third Reich forced the Greek National Bank to lend Hitler's Germany 476 million reichsmarks interest-free. After Germany's surrender, the Allied powers organized the Paris Conference on Reparations in the fall of 1945. Greece laid claim to $10 billion, or half the total amount of $20 billion the Soviets suggested that Germany pay. The suffering caused to Greece by the Nazis is undeniable. Yet at the same time, human suffering cannot really be measured. Independent historians unanimously agree that the total economically measurable damages suffered by Greece as a result of the German occupation, in both absolute numbers as well as proportionate to the population, put Greece in fourth place after Poland, the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia. (Is the Greek bailout falling apart?) At the Paris Conference on Reparations, Greece was finally accorded 4.5% in material German reparation and 2.7% in other forms of reparations. Practically, this meant that Greece received mainly material goods — like machines made in West Germany — worth approximately $25 million, which in today's money amounts to as much as $2.7 billion. However, the stipulations made at the Paris conference were all but irrelevant given that the U.S. opposed heavy economic penalties. U.S. leaders recalled what happened after World War I, when Germany's first democracy, the Weimar Republic, was massively weakened economically by having to pay off reparations. Indeed, one of the consequences of this policy was the rise of Hitler.


All Four Allies Agreed - That is why under the terms of the 1953 London Debt Agreement, reparation payments were put off until a peace treaty was signed. That finally happened in 1990, which didn't require Germany to pay further reparations to other countries like Greece. Greece accepted the treaty, though clearly it had little choice. After decades of partnership with Germany (Greece has been a member of NATO since 1952 and associated with European organizations since 1961), it would have been politically difficult to demand huge reparations — although the issue of compensation was periodically raised by Greek politicians, mostly to score points in domestic politics. (source : Time )

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

The main problem with an exit from the eurozone is the transition period. Capital controls will have to be imposed. Temporary measures to ration foreign exchange for the importation of petroleum and other essential items will have to be undertaken. How will the Bank of Greece settle with the ECB? How will debt be converted from euros to drachmas?

It is clear that a tremendous amount of preparatory work is needed both for default and for exit from the eurozone, and much of it has to be undertaken in utter secrecy. Still, it has to be done – even if one were to disagree with exit from the eurozone. The reason is that such preparations would also enhance Greece's bargaining position with the troika. Instead of laughing at empty threats of renegotiation, as has occurred twice with the current finance minister, the troika would see that the government means business.

If the current Greek government can't or doesn't want to take such necessary measures that will preserve the country and its people, it should yield the field – with or without elections – to other political forces that are willing to do so

Anonymous said...

On September 15, it was revealed that the forthright entrepreneur had agreed to accept gold bullion as a security deposit on a lease for a floor of the Trump Building on Wall Street. The gold was estimated to be worth about $180,000 (£115,704).

"The legacy of gold as a precious commodity has transcended to become a viable currency and an accepted universal monetary standard," Mr Trump said.

However, since the man nicknamed "The Donald" unveiled the decision the gold price has slumped by about $175 an ounce. Did his characteristically bold statement mark the top of gold's bull run?

The price falls were prompted by a sharp reversal in risk aversion boosting the dollar. This was caused by the debt crisis in the eurozone and the US Federal Reserve's decision not to launch a third round of quantitative easing.

Anonymous said...

There's been regrettably little optimism on display among world leaders over the past week, only a feeling of growing alarm. But equally regrettably, it is with good reason.

Among bankers and policymakers in Washington for the annual meeting of the International Monetary Fund, the mood was one of unrelenting gloom. Many thought both Europe and the US already effectively back in recession.

There was also gathering concern over the state of until now booming Asian economies. China is slowing fast, and at least two of Asia's tiger economies are heading into technical recession, something that hasn't happened since the emerging markets crisis nearly 15 years ago.

On the basis that the mood among bankers and policymakers is a generally quite poor guide to what's really going on, it would be nice to take a contrary stance and argue that things are not quite as bad as they seem.

Unfortunately, it would not be justified. If there are opportunities out there, they are very hard to see, other than the faintly fatuous observation that there is nothing like a bad downturn to galvanise much-needed improvements in competitiveness. But in the meantime, policy misjudgement and indecision in Europe threaten complete calamity

Anonymous said...

Pacific Investment Management Co., which runs the world’s biggest bond fund, is forecasting that advanced economies will stall over the next year as Europe slides into a recession, underscoring mounting investor concern about the global economic outlook.
There will be little-to-no economic growth in industrial nations in the coming 12 months as Europe’s economy shrinks by 1 percent to 2 percent and the U.S. stagnates, said Mohamed El- Erian, chief executive officer of Newport Beach, California-based Pimco. That will leave worldwide expansion at about 2.5 percent, less than the 4 percent forecast by the International Monetary Fund this year and next.

Such gloomy sentiment dominated weekend talks of policy makers, investors and bankers in Washington, where the IMF and World Bank held their annual meetings. The Dow Jones Industrial Average suffered its biggest loss since 2008 last week as the Federal Reserve said risks to the U.S. economy had increased and Europe’s debt crisis went unresolved.




Read more: Pimco's El-Erian: European Recession to Stall World Growth
Important: Can you afford to Retire? Shocking Poll Results

Anonymous said...

World Waits

“Wait a few more days,” said Regling, when asked for details.

Finance officials will also discuss this week speeding implementation of a permanent rescue plan by a year to next July, according to a working paper obtained by Bloomberg News. ECB Governing Council members Ewald Nowotny and Luc Coene signaled in interviews in Washington that the central bank may say next week it will begin offering banks unlimited liquidity for as long as a year.

Greek Finance Minister Evangelos Venizelos said his country “wants to make it and will make it” and that it will always be a member of the euro area. Prime Minister George Papandreou said yesterday that the EU must take “strategic decisions” and that the end of the global economic crisis “appears even more distant.”



Read more: Pimco's El-Erian: European Recession to Stall World Growth
Important: Can you afford to Retire? Shocking Poll Results